More recently, when state police believed an unsolved John Doe murder in the late 1960s might be solved with DNA analysis, they exhumed the body for evidence. Former Briarcliff Manor Police Sergeant Ronald Langer remains a suspect. They recalled how one of their uncles had researched the family tree then stopped, mysteriously. Kathleens body has never been found. For Gleason, the big mystery surrounding the case always has been what caused Sherri to get off the Taconic where she did. Warmus is serving her 25-years-to-life sentence in Bedford Hills Correctional Facility. But in death, they shared an awful distinction as the victims in three of the oldest unsolved killings in Westchester County. A classic whodunit, this case may never close, leaving us to wonder, With so many adversaries, did Rosenberg have this coming?. Homicide cases have to be worked on. His parents insist it was not plausible for him to leave without warning, and his coworkers at the Dutchess Diner on Route 9, where Tony worked as a waiter for several years, said he was a hard-working, trouble-free employee. WebIOWA: A double homicide in Newton committed in 1983 remains unsolved. When police found his stash of photos featuring young women and men in provocative poses, they feared that Alcala may have been responsible for the murders of as many as 130 victims. Located on 400 acres, Dutchs Spirits was built around the four bunkers and escape tunnels built into the hillside. Although it was successful for him, he didnt want that kind of clientele in the bar., The Best New Westchester Restaurants Serving Authentic CuisineFrom Real Chinese Food To Artisanal Italian, Westchester Restaurants Are Upgrading Dorm Room Classics. In 2008, she won a lawsuit against the Department of Correctional Services and was awarded $10,000. It was like a bad B-movie, recalls Paul Orofino with a sad laugh. When Rukaj arrived, Nikc pulled out a revolver and blasted a bullet into his gut. Jeff ultimately took the car into the city. Then he watched his mother die in 2010, taking her sorrow to the grave., Louies brother and sister have moved on, but he hasnt. She believed they would do her and her family no harm. Every night, Louie and his dad, a Filipino immigrant who worked as a laser mechanic, would move their cars out of the driveway so Louies mother and Victors wife, Lourdes, a nurse who worked a late shift at a Yonkers nursing home, could park closest to the house. Its difficult, tedious, and, often, heartbreaking work, but its not altogether hopeless. Soundstages and the Hudson Valleys First Backlot Are Coming to iPark 84, Heres How to Spend a Relaxing Weekend in Rhinebeck. I looked up and down the river valley, staring at this, he says. Keels dead, Yonkers Police Department Cold Case Detective John Geiss says of the murder of 60-year-old David Keels, a Yonkers resident killed on February 7, 1997. They had met two years earlier at the Greenville Elementary School in Scarsdale where they both taught and had had an affair. That way, the cars would be arranged in the driveway so that Victor and Louie both could leave for work in the morning. The 2014 Pix11 story quotes a 1996 interview she gave to a local publication, the Patent Trader, in which she defended her decision to get a lawyer. The murders remain unsolved. She was naked from the waist down, her jumble of bright red hair still beautiful. He tried to prevent people from coming in with drugs and weapons, and there were incidents where he had kicked people out, says Geiss, who believes those incidents may provide clues to the motive for the killing. All of them went to the electric chair.. WebTry refreshing the page. In 2006, river-goers claimed to have seen an enormous manatee, more commonly found around Florida, swimming near the Chelsea Piers in Manhattan and on up into Westchester County waters. State Police are again looking for leads in the unsolved Double Initial murder cases. Most people get lawyers. Louie jumped out of his car and chased him, but lost him after about a block. The Hudson River, not to be outdone, has Kipsy. The first suspect was an unidentified foreigner named Florentine Chase, a suspicious fellow who had been seen in the area that day but fled in a hired auto to catch a train out of New York City that evening. I cant say for sure it was a spaceship. He never asked to look at the bill. Lanzetta added that Rosenberg had visited his deli the day he died, ordering his usual a slice of mushroom pizza and a glass of water. The couple had been married less than a year. But ProjectColdCase.org, a national organization dedicated to publicizing cold cases, reports that, between 1980 and 2008, there were 45,740 murders in New York He castrated and mutilated them. His wife, Narcy Novack, a former exotic dancer, told police that she had found her bloodied, 53-year-old husbands bodyhis eyes gouged out, his head caved inin their hotel room after returning from having breakfast alone. Jeff Edwards, Patch Staff. This individual had an alibi, but we think it may have been arranged and he refused to cooperate and take a polygraph., Despite this, Hoff adds the strike-related theory cant be ruled out. Frank Umbrino, who oversees the department's Major Crimes Unit, there are 554 unsolved homicides in Rochester. He was paroled in 2005, rearrested for not following the conditions of his parole, and paroled again in 06. Before, her daughter from her first marriage, Anne Morrell Petrillo, had come to visit. In 1980, she was sentenced to 15 years to life and sent to Bedford Hills. He became a loner and drifted throughout the country before settling in Galveston, Texas, where he spent much of his time living as a woman. Paul readily agreed to take several polygraph tests during which he was subjected to intense interrogations. Geiss believes it has something to do with the bar he owned, Bo Dicks Lounge (Bo Dicks was Davids nickname) on Warburton Avenue. Westchester County is known for its good schools, picturesque golf courses, and cul de sac communities that are the glamorous gateway to the worlds most famous city. Schultz, who once said, If I had kept the name Flegenheimer, nobody would have heard of me, has managed to keep his name alive in the Hudson Valley to this day. Aurnou maintains that Tarnower was shot in the hand trying to prevent Harris from killing herself. One of the most popular stories is that Schultz and [bodyguard] Lulu Rosenkranz carried a steel safe containing the loot to Phoenicia on an April night in 1933 and buried it in a grove of pine trees near the Esopus, with the obligatory X marking the spot. He then shot and killed her father-in-law. His killing spree likely ran from 1996-2010, with the victims discovered between 2010-2011. Realtor Dalia Valdes of Julia B. Every January, the Pleasantville Fire Department hosts a memorial in Tom Dorrs honor at Graham Hills Park, near where he was murdered. On the night of January 31, 1982, 29-year-old Kathleen McCormack was driven by her husband Robert Durst from their home in South Salem, New York, to a Westchester train station. He now awaits execution at San Quentin. When questioned by police, Durst, they noted, was remarkably calm for a man whose wife was missing. Sandy woke me up and said, Tony never came home, Anthony told The Poughkeepsie Journal. Some have remained unsolved for more than a century some cases are more recent, but perhaps just as cold. The lights were moving in a V or triangle shape, and colors would change into shapes that looked like unknown letters, like it was trying to communicate something to who I dont know. There was light coming from it, but it appeared to go from the ground up instead of from the object down. Next came the big house in Rye, the wealthy lifestyle, and a love affair with a 25-year-old married woman, Rigaletta Nikc. And we want to get them those answers, and we want to get them that justice. So he became Dutch Schultz, one of the biggest and baddest gangsters of Prohibition-era America. Like the woman found in When she entered Tarnowers bedroom suite, she found lingerie that belonged to the secretary. A man's shirt was discovered, with what appeared to be blood stains, under a bridge on the road leading to White Plains. When he got to his home in Greenburghs Scarsdale Ridge Apartments just before midnight, he found his wife, face down on the living room floor, covered in blood. Posing as a Long Island farmer offering to hire the Budd familys son Edward, he met and became obsessed with their 10-year-old daughter, Grace. We still dont know why. Urciuoli has been missing ever since. They were part of the powerless class. There were rumors that the short, round, and balding man, per The New York Times, had also been stabbed numerous times, his throat was cut, and he was actually shot three times. Some say that the place was bewitched, he reports, and its people are given to all kinds of marvelous beliefs, are subject to trances and visions, and frequently see strange sights, and hear music and voices in the air. Tracys mother, Joyce, told a pastor shortly before her death in 2013 that she wasnt ready to go yet because she was holding out hope of finding out who killed her husband. Related: Mamaroneck detective discusses Spina slaying. The same was true of Mr. King, who was, it turned out, one of the few people around claiming to have actually seen the second half of the gravestone., According to The Times, King had given rubbings of the stone to Brennan and to Chris Sonne, the historian for the town of Tuxedo neither of whom had actually seen the stone with his own eyes. Amy thought I was crazy., He has since read everything he can find about this and other unexplained flying phenomena. The I saw her dead body, dumped in a vacant lot in the Bronx, in Sept. of 1980. The investigation has focused on the Nodine Hill neighborhood of Yonkers where Serbay lived. The New York district attorney plans to extradite him for prosecution. Jaromir Chalabala/Shutterstock Steven Fisher, 20, and his girlfriend Melisa Gregory, 17, were bludgeoned to death on a ranch northwest of Newton, Iowa, in 1983. The two were at an underage drinking party in Harrison when Viscome made a remark about Patricks father and the younger Rukaj threw a punch. It was a monster snowstorm. It was an immense operation, and we consider the bunkers to be the real buried treasure.. The wait is agonizing for them, but we dont give up, and we do care.. Her case has taken many twists and turns over the years and is now in the hands of the CCAC. Most of North America has Bigfoot. They both strongly doubted that this Thomas Jefferson was the son of that Thomas Jefferson. Durst provides his own chilling commentary track. A frozen male corpse was found on February 1, 1970 in Saugerties, Ulster County, New York, at the bottom of a hill near a highway by two children who were out sledding. 1. I tried to hold it together the best I could, he recalls. Jeff said [Tom] changed his mind. Witnesses recalled seeing a blonde woman pulled over by a cop around the time Sherri likely would have been passing through the area, based on when she left her friends in Queens. On September 11, 1996, Rukaj went to Nikcs house in Mount Pleasant to, he would later claim, discuss his future role in raising their then five-year-old daughter. In 1977, Rodney Alcala, who often used the pseudonym John Berger, was in NYUs film school studying under Roman Polanski. There was also the time that Ben broke Narcys nose, and she went to a plastic surgeon to get it repaired. The body of respected Kensico attorney Albert Montfort was found Sept. 5, 1882, in a pool of blood on the floor, his head, nearly severed, resting on his right arm, with his left ear cut off and deep gashes on his neck, forehead and the top of his skull. Check out 11 of Westchesters Most Twisted Crimes. Aderson and the other driver got into an argument. Paul was shocked to find he was one of the prime suspects. Aderson died en route to St. Lukes Hospital in Newburgh. It has to be actively investigated, and thats monitored to make sure it happens, says Investigator Timothy Gleason of the New York State Police Troop K barracks in Cortlandt. The investigationintoLauren Spierer's 2011 disappearance brings to mind other high-profile casesin the Lower Hudson Valley that have remained as yet unsolved. She claimed she was forced to have sex with correction officers to receive privileges. A retired schoolteacher named Marshall Jacobs dug into the mystery in the mid-1980s, interviewing Coxs family, friends, and classmates; CIA, FBI, and CID agents; and West Point and Army officials; and pouring over files acquired through the Freedom of Information Act. Though there is no clear murder motive, investigators believe it had to do with drugs and/or prostitution. Calabrese doesnt agree. He was aged between 35 and 45 and had been shot four times. And I dont think anyone is going to take that risk of murdering her off the grounds and then transporting her to dump her body., Even with little to go on, investigators are not giving up. Today, Jane Sawyer lives in the Torrington area of Connecticut and has mostly declined interviews over the years. On April 26, 1970, 11-year-old Terrence Terry Bowers was found deceased, suffering from multiple stab wounds while on a Boy Scout camping trip. The victim was approximately 5 feet 3 inches tall and weighed about 155 pounds. Earlier in the day, he had fought with Tom because he had run out of heroin and wanted to use Toms four-wheel-drive car to go into New York City and buy drugs. Zanza, not knowing what else to do, plunged a dagger into Halls chest. According to Capt. Recently, 100 of his fellow Algonquins had been slaughtered by the Dutch settlers. People in the drug world and the prostitution world report something that they heard from so-and-so, who heard from so-and-so, that this person was involved. LINDA MISEK-FALKOFF : Police said that Linda Misek-Falkoff was found Oct. 30, 2014 in her Pleasantville home after what appeared to be a burglary. Why did somebody whos leaving one location and supposed to be going to another stop at this spot? he asks. If that doesn't work, there may be a network issue, and you can use our self test page to see what's preventing the page from loading. His legend, however, lives on to this day, in the village of Phoenicia, where, or so it is believed, Schultz buried a metal safe containing diamonds, gold, and millions of dollars in cash and bonds. Witnesses saw two white males in their 20s wearing white T-shirts approach the victim shortly before they heard gunshots. She was there to socialize, but she was also trying to spend some time away from her husband, Robert. Incensed, she confronted Tarnower, who, in turn, slapped her and told her she was crazy. His parents appeared on Montel Williams TV show with psychic Sylvia Browne in desperate search for information. The case remains unsolved after 44 years. WebThe Unsolved Murder of Ruth Whitman The students are also working on the 60-year-old unsolved cold case of Ruth Whitman. WebIf you have any information please contact Rochester Crime Stoppers at 585-423-9300. They have offered substantial rewards and hired private detectives. An intense manhunt followed. The case went cold. Geiss rotates through these, keeping about 30 on his work board and actively investigating about 10 at a time. She also called Paul to tell him the same thing. Prosecutors believe that Narcy also may have been behind that death. Police determined that she had been raped and strangled. But it wasnt until January of this year that he was indicted for the murder of Ellen Jane Hover. Her body, ironically, was discovered after a postal employee noticed mail piling up. If you have information regarding this case, contact Investigator Robert Mollica at 914.788.8044. His car, however, was discovered parked on the Tappan Zee Bridge with a bloody hammer still inside of it. There were rumors in the family, the women said, that he had discovered the connection between Jefferson and his mistress, and the uncle did not want to know more., Some of the reporters then trekked to the John Coffey Jr. WebSome of the oldest unsolved murders on Uncovered s cold case website include the 1960 murder of Nancy Eagleson, the 1977 murder of Ann Harmeier, the 1977 murder of Roberta Elam, the 1982 murder of Tina Foglia, the 1980 murder of Eve Wilkowitz, and the 1984 murder of Laura Parker. If you see them, do not try and apprehend them yourself as they are most likely armed and dangerous. Solomon told his wife, Betty Jeanne, 40, that he was heading to the bowling alley that night. They were talking about this, and I jumped off the couch and yelled, Oh, my god! He practiced every known perversion found in medical texts and came up with a few of his own that no one had ever heard of. But that morning, Wampage led his men to the Hutchinson estate, killing Anne and five of her children. Hutchinson embraced the people native to the area, so when the warning call went out for all white settlers to flee because of the Siwanoys, she ignored it. For Louie Atienza, the horror has never subsided. He proposed as much to the Syndicate of mob bosses, who voted against it. In 2011, Victoria, the toddler who had witnessed her mothers murder and is now 21, was arrested in Vermont for possession of heroin. While the loot may or may not exist, another buried treasure of sorts has been unearthed by Dutchs Spirits, a new venture in Pine Plains, where Schultzs actual underground bootlegging compound has been distilled into a boutique whiskey-making operation and museum. MOUNT VERNON, NY Westchester County Crime Stoppers has announced that it is offering a record $7,500 reward for information that leads to an arrest and Because he expected to be working until about midnight each night, his wife, Sherri Orofino, decided to spend a few nights with friends in Queens, where both of them had grown up. Paul and Sherri had moved out of Manhattan to Millbrook, in Dutchess County, only a few months earlier. He then cut her body up and brought it back to his New York City apartment where he made a stew out of it and consumed it over the next week while compulsively masturbating. Wampage and his men wanted revenge and they didnt care what white settlers had to pay for the Dutchs sins. On March 27, 2009, the strangled body of Sabrina Rasa was found by a groundskeeper behind a vacant building on the grounds of the Veterans Affairs Hospital in Montrose. Back in 1980, the mob was absolutely involved in the sanitation industry, so we cant overlook that angle, either., If you have information regarding this case, contact Investigator John Shaughnessy at 914.788.8044.. His brother, who had been in the house, came out. Get Started Now. Do You Know Where to Find the Hudson Valleys Missing Sundial? Rewards of up to $25,000 were offered for information. It was a murder for hire, says Investigator John Shaughnessy of the New York State Police Troop K barracks in Cortlandt. After his brief stint at NYU, Alcala moved back to California without graduating and, in 1978, he appeared on that quintessential 70s show, The Dating Game. The motion picture All Good Things, released in December 2010 and starring Ryan Gosling and Kirsten Dunst, is based on Durst and his relationship with Kathleen. The end result: Jacobs decided he had learned all he was going to, Maihafer writes, and he accepted the fact that neither he nor anyone else would ever know the full story.. Cox is the only West Point cadet who ever disappeared without being found dead or alive. She had two boyfriends at the time of her death. DAVID CUSE ALHUAY : The body of 39-year-old David Cuse Alhuay wasfound in his Bedford yard Dec. 26, 2015. New York does not track cold cases by county or provide data on the total number of them in the state. Prior to his murder, David had partnered with someone to promote weekend parties (Geiss declined to provide this individuals name because he remains a person of interest in the case). Its very hard to resist Carolyn, Solomon would later testify. Edward Tompkins was shot once in the head and twice in the chest. When Sabrinas body was found behind vacant Building 11, the rumors started flying. WebSome of the oldest unsolved murders on Uncovered s cold case website include the 1960 murder of Nancy Eagleson, the 1977 murder of Ann Harmeier, the 1977 murder of Roberta Elam, the 1982 murder of Tina Foglia, the 1980 murder of Eve Wilkowitz, and the 1984 murder of Laura Parker. She also worked in the prison nursery and taught parenting classes for the inmates with children. Geiss, who remains in regular contact with Tracy Keels, is optimistic that eventually this will happen. Investigator Timothy Gleason, with the New York State Police Troop K barracks in Cortlandt, says Langer works for the New York State Department of Labor in upstate New York and remains a suspect in the case. When the police arrived at the Douglas home, they found Anne covered in blood, her new terrier puppy whimpering by her side, and the Douglass three-year-old daughter, Victoria, at the foot of the bed. On July 12, 2009, Florida millionaire Ben Novack, Jr., was found bludgeoned to death at the Hilton Rye Town. The story, according to a 2014 Pix11.com article, was that Jane and her son, Jeff Dorr, Toms stepson, went into the woods with Tom to feed the turkeys, but left Tom quickly because of the weather conditions. We dont feel that she was killed off the property and transported to the VA, just because they do have a police department that patrols the grounds, Hoff says. They gave a brief description, but it ended up that they got the wrong license plate on the car, so the attempts to locate the vehicle were negative.. The men spoke very little English. These events were successful but caused issues with drug use and sales. I saw that! It came rushing back like a movie flashback. It was an older bar, and what happened was that a younger crowd started moving in.. The landlord was murdered Nov. 9, 1995. Loch Ness has Nessie. So its very disheartening, Tracy says. In the immediate aftermath of her fathers murder, Tracy was optimistic that those involved would be swiftly brought to justice. Contractors say he tried to renegotiate deals after their work had been done. He was arrested for shoplifting a chicken salad sandwich, a newspaper, and Band-Aids from a supermarket in Pennsylvania.